Monday, July 23, 2012

#ModChem Day 9: Part 2 - Development of Subatomic Particles

Modeler's Log, Day 9--

After we finished with our thought-provoking whiteboarding session and article discussion, which you can read about in detail here, we continued through the historical development of the atomic model to the existence of a subatomic particle that has negative charge. This was accomplished using explorations into the work of Faraday, Crooks and Thomson.

We conducted (heheh..."conducted") the sticky tape lab where we tested the attraction and repulsion of Scotch tape strips to different materials, which led us to arrive at a need for particles smaller than an atom; moreover, the conclusion that a negatively charged particle (later called an electron) must exist inside of the atom! The "Sticky Tape Lab" (which can be found in its full modeling entirety on the AMTA website) is a rework of a classic physics electrostatics lab. This lab provided students an opportunity to test the behavior of strips of tape, which had been ripped apart from each other, when in brought in proximity to aluminum, paper, glass, and other ripped apart strips of tape.
We generated three possible expected outcomes during the design and setup of the lab, including that materials would attract, repel, or do nothing. After testing all the materials against each other, we constructed a matrix that displayed the results:

Based on our results, we determined the charge of each piece of the tape and thus the charge on the other materials as well. Following a very informative video about cathode rays and the experiments surrounding them, the model development to arrive at the existence of charged subatomic particles was complex but happened--this will take carefully crafted planning to do with students, but was really impressive because of how it followed a similar development of the charge model in physics.

Our model developed to accommodate the transfer and flow of charged particles, as well as help us to characterize our newly "discovered" charged particle. We were able to represent charged particles inside of the atom in a primitive way along with introduce a new property: conductivity! As it turns out, the model we arrived at was that of J.J. Thomson's "plum pudding," but it explained all that we had seen quite well. In context with what we have been doing all year, it makes sense to arrive at this model of the atom at this time; however, there was copious discontent with even exploring this model much more than out of honorable mention considering what we currently know about atomic theory.

It's important to note here that the atomic models developed throughout history are NOT merely artifacts but rather evidence-based and well-reasoned attempts to explain the science behind matter and its interactions. All too often, the "history of the atom" chapter is glossed over in chemistry classes by students, because it has the word "history" in it, and by teachers who rush through it to get to the "true (current) stuff" about the atom. I have to admit that I used to be one of those teachers; however, I was never given a full understanding of the development of the atomic model and now I have a MUCH greater appreciation for it and see how important it is in understanding chemistry. Though it may seem unnatural to follow chemistry through a chronological progression of atomic model development, we cannot reduce the model development to mere prestidigitation and page turning in a textbook. This methodology doesn't just honor the "history of the atom," it simulates the models of the atom historically and in context with the associated chemistry that was known at all the points along the way. Resist the urge at this point in the curriculum to jump to a "full-blown" model of the atom that uses all the common jargon, even if it is true that students "already know" that atoms have these subatomic particles. Stick with plum pudding and let the rest come in time.

As a final aside, I always wondered who ever liked plum pudding anyway, I never remember Bill Cosby advertising it! Then again, I shouldn't knock it before I try it. Perhaps we'll just have to make some plum pudding this year in chemistry and taste it for ourselves! That'd be memorable, right?!


  1. This is very useful and inspiring for people who want to build something from the comfort of their homes. Even though it looks very hard, building things is actually very easy. All you have to do is follow these looks very easy and I will definitely try!

  2. I concur with your conclusions and will certainly thirstily look forward to your forthcoming updates. Saying thanks can not simply be sufficient, for the exceptional lucidity write my assignment for me in your writing. I can instantly grab your rss feed to stay abreast of any updates. Authentic work and also much success in your business dealings!

  3. There are so many online assignment help website to help you. It is important to choose the best one among the many. Before choosing the one go for that website reviews first and then check the website like their services, prices, discounts, website interface, and everything. Go through their samples that how they write so, you can understand the level of their experts.
    Programming Help

  4. Thanks for sharing informative stuff on Assignment Help! You have explained all relevant information on writing services in this write-up. Students who are struggling for higher marks can visit greatassignmenthelp to place their order for quick help.
    Assignment Help Online
    Online Assignment Help
    Assignment Help Online Services
    Assignment Helper
    Assignment Assistance
    Assignment Help Experts
    Online Assignment Help Services
    Assignment Writing Help

  5. Hii i am donaldgeorge and i am a senior technician in Quickbooks .If you face any technical issues in quickbooks then must dialQuickbooks Support Phone Number

  6. We all know Quicken is one of the expenses controlling and budgeting management tool. It is used on a large scale by a small businessman or an individual. However, this software is convenient and easy to use when you are familiar with its functions. But sometime user of Quicken faces some issue. This issue can be created because of technical reason. If you face any issue you can contact Quicken Customer Service for assistance.

    convert QuickBooks to Quicken
    Quicken Password not working
    Quicken Password problems
    Quicken one step update not working
    quicken cloud sync errors
    quicken can't open your data file
    Quicken Error HTTP 504
    convert quicken to QuickBooks
    Quicken Error CC-501
    Quicken Error CC-502
    quicken error cc-503

  7. A printer is an indispensable machine that is used to print softcopy of any document into a hardcopy format. The significance of printers is beyond doubt in public as well as in private sectors. Although we have all the documents and information stored in the digital format, but the requirement of a printer is still exists to take these information out on paper. Among the several printer brands, the quality of HP printer is surpassing every level of satisfaction. However, these printers also display some error codes and stop printing at once. In that condition, you don’t need to be afraid just make a call at HP Customer Support Phone Number and take assistance from deft professionals.

    hp customer support
    hp customer support number
    hp customer support phone number
    hp printer customer support
    hp printer customer support number
    hp printer customer support phone number

  8. Your blog is very informative and interesting Sometimes, while installing Garmin express map on your windows system, you may stumble upon some issues. You may have faced error like installation failed or installer not launch properly. Then you should try some effective ways such as checking specific error; restart your computer, unblocking the installer, ending Microsoft installer processes, etc. You can also try to get free Garmin GPS Update from its official site. If none of these helps or you requires some more additional support, then you can dial toll-free number and take assistance from ingenious professionals. They will certainly assist you in eliminating your entire issues within a stipulated time frame.
    Garmin GPS Updates
    Garmin Map Update
    Garmin GPS Updates

  9. “Get rid of Canon B200 error with the help of our experts”
    The blunder B200 Error on the Canon Printer indicates that the print head has died. Before you go for condemning the printer or buying a new one, try these suggestions to overcome Canon B200 error. These are the basic steps to deal with any sort of error.
    1. Remove all the ink cartridges and reinstall the new one.
    2. Take out the Print Head and thoroughly clean all of the gold contacts on the print head itself.
    Try these steps, if these won’t work for you, talk to our experts and get the 100% effective solution. Dial our toll free number and eliminate this error instantly.
    Canon B200 Error
    Canon Wireless Printer Setup
    Connect Canon Printer To Wi-Fi
    Canon printer offline

  10. What Are The Steps Of Canon Wireless Printer Setup?
    Are you wandering for getting an effective ideas of how to Canon Wireless Printer Setup? Willing to know the exact procedure of connecting wireless Canon printer? If yes, then do one thing, just put a ring on our 24/7 accessible helpline number and get associate with the techies who answer your call Canon technician. They will direct you on phone the entire steps with an ease without taking a single penny from you as we are offering free of cost services to our helpless customers. Therefore, if you don’t have money but still want to troubleshoot any kind of Canon Printer Offline related problems, hassle-freely, keep in touch with us.
    Canon error code 5b00
    Canon B200 Error
    Canon Wireless Printer Setup
    Connect Canon Printer To Wi-Fi
    Canon printer offline

  11. Hello, I'm the first visit here and quit impress with your post. This is very useful and attractive. Many Students need CDR Report Help but they don't know how to get the best quality assignment help. so don't worry we have here My expert team providing high-quality assignment help for Students you have simply contact our expert team we have available 24*7. You have also visited our website MyAssignmentHelpAu.

  12. Watch latest news of automobile industry on automartz this website daily basis update. You can read international or nation news and we also provide career news, auto news, super cars news etc.
    Business section

    Hello and Welcome to
    It has been a dream come true for the entire Indian Automobile industry to be listed on a single platform.
    With the enormous setup consisting a massive range of raw to finished products in Automobile industry, we are undisputed and No.1 Organization in providing the details of Authentic Manufacturers, Exporters, Importers, Distributors, Dealers, Retailers of the Automobile industry and its related industries onto a single platform enabling every user to reach their desired destination.
    If you're looking to be associated with us by advertising for your Business, please send a mail to and our team will contact you shortly. However, If you are looking to be associated with us in more ways, kindly send us your details of proposal in email to

    antenna adapter for tata ace mega 2032148
    audio terminal and connector for eicher pro 1059 2120161
    Manitou me 420 second hand 3470
    TaTa 407

  13. Thanks for taking the time to discuss this, I feel strongly about it and love learning more on this topic. If possible, as you gain expertise, would you mind updating your blog with more information? It is extremely helpful for me.

    Computer Science Assignment Help

    Management Assignment Help

    Online Assignment Help

    Accounting Assignment Help

  14. so happy to find good place to many here in the post, the writing is just great, thanks for the post. do my essay


  15. Are you looking to turn on the keyboard lights? Find the simple steps to turn on HP omen keyboard lights.

    Turn On HP Omen Keyboard Lights !! Laptop Not Recognizing Headphones

  16. I (Sneha) must say that....Everything thought about when someone doesn't have the foggiest idea in regards to some time later its up to different people that they will help, so here it happens. Visit .. SPSS Help

  17. Great post. I was checking constantly this post and I am impressed! Very helpful information. assignment helps

  18. so glad to discover great spot to numerous here in the post, the composing is simply extraordinary, a debt of gratitude is in order for the post. assignment helps

  19. For the students who are looking to take Online assignment help, we are all set to provide the best service. We provide assignment help online to all the student across the world. At reasonable rates, you can avail of our services. Our dedicated, hardworking and talented professionals would complete your assignment whether it is of any subject within the promised time. Also, we ensure that your assignment is done on time without any error. So, don’t think twice, just approach us and leave the worry of your assignment.

  20. If you are looking for a reliable IT solution provider for your IT business then MICSupport will definitely help you. We are a leading web design, development and digital marketing service provider. We have years of experience in this filed and deliver timely service to the customers. You can avail our services to manage your IT business in a better way.

  21. World of Devotion is an online religious and spiritual portal that is offering religious and spiritual services to the devotees in Haridwar. We serve clean, pure, and Satvik Bhojan to eleven Brahmains with the great respect by the Vedic procedure at Haridwar Dham. Our Acharyas of Brahman Bhoj, Haridwar request Brahmins to take part in the Vedic ritual of feeding Brahman Bhoj to fulfill the desires of the devotee.