Tuesday, July 17, 2012

#ModChem Day 6

Modeler's Log, Day 6--

The second week started off with just as much energy as the first.

We started off with a hearty discussion of Testing for Conceptual Understanding in General Chemistry by Craig W. Bowen and Diane Bunce. This was perhaps our best article-based discussion thus far in the workshop. The article dealt with misconceptions in chemistry that have been elucidated by a number of researchers on the topic as well as assessment strategies to address misconceptions.
We were prompted to decide how we will change our assessments in the future to reflect our knowledge of misconceptions. There was a tremendous exchane in which participants discussed many great ideas, including:
  • Assessments for measuring individual progress (summative assessments and formative assessments) vs. measuring whole group progress (Modeling chemistry's Assessment of Basic Chemistry Concepts, ABCC) 
  • Paired or linked questions (like on the ABCC) or the sets of questions where the second question depends on answer to first 
  • Open-ended constructed response questions instead of mere multiple choice questions 
  • Conceptual questions vs. algorithmic questions 
  • To allow/permit test-corrections or reassessments and the value of learning from mistakes on tests 
  • Writing "good" or plausible distractors that address different misconceived lines of thinking and rules of assessment question writing 
  • Test questions often ask for critical thinking from students, but if teachers don't provide opportunities for students to practice critical thinking during class, then the assessment isn't fair 
  • When we "teach" something in class and then assess something similar, but only to find that the students weren't able to do it, we as educators conclude: "the students weren't able to do..." instead of "what did I the teacher do that led to this?" 
  • Do conceptual questions or explanatory open-ended and constructed response questions "hurt" students who have language issues? 
  • In the "real world," people have resources and life-lines, why don't we provide those parameters more in a classroom assessment setting? 
  • Teaching to a test vs. teaching to standards (when to create/generate your assessment: before teaching or after teaching?)
After this rich discussion, we moved on to a lab--the most EXCITING lab of the year--the water heating curve lab.We took some ice in a beaker and heated it through changes of state and temperature changes until it boiled. This lab took quite some time, but since we had so much fun doing it, we forgot about the time. 


Here is the lab, condensed in to about a minute and a half through stop-motion animation video:


 
After debriefing the lab on the heating of water through temperature and phase changes, we arrived at a representation for the energy storage and transfer in in the system that represented the changes that were taking place. We were able to infer that though energy was constantly being transferred from the hot plate to the water in the beaker, when the temperature wasn't changing the energy was still being transferred somewhere. The destination of the energy transfer was the distance between the particles (the arrangement of the particles) represented by the Eph, or energy of phase. This was contrasted by the regions of the curve where there was a temperature change, and in that case we recognized that the energy was being transferred to the energy associated with the particles' motion (thermal energy.) 

Our exploration into energy transfers and storage moved from there to constructing a representation of the storage and transfer of energy using bar graphs, fondly referred to as "LOL" diagrams. These diagrams provide students a visual way to describe the energy stored in a system and transferred between a system and its surroundings. This handy and cognitive way of representing energy prevents energy from being vague to students and provides a way for them to think through situations and problems involving energy quantification and transfer.

Once we had a way to represent energy, it was on to represent the energy storage and transfer in the heating of water experiment using bar charts. The LOL diagrams were connected to points on the heat curve and this allowed us to see what was happening with the energy, more transparently, during the different stages of the heating of water. For some background on the treatment of energy in the modeling approach, see Larry Dukerich's presentation on a coherent treatment of energy.

After learning how to treat energy in different situations, we deployed our model for representing energy storage and transfer on the corresponding unit homework worksheets. Then, we whiteboarded and discussed some problems and their solutions. By the end, we had a pretty strong understanding of how to represent energy in a variety of settings.


23 comments:

  1. You have described the importance of education in very efficient manners. I was not known these things before then i visit cheap essay writing services it provided my something very interesting . A one should read your article to know about how important education is for us. People are now very sluggish to learn new things.

    ReplyDelete
  2. You can check out modchem to see more ideas from the workshop today and over the next three weeks. I’m looking forward to seeing where this all takes us over the next few weeks Write My Custom Essay For Me Cheap but even just today has me sold on using this in my chemistry teaching in the future. It’s tough to reproduce the experience in words, you just have to try and see it for yourself sometime if you can.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Good post i like it my opinion is arrived at a representation for the energy storage and transfer in within the system that represented the changes that were happening . We were ready to infer that though energy was constantly being transferred from the recent plate to the water within the beaker, when the temperature wasn't changing the energy was still being transferred somewhere. The destination of the energy transfer was the space between the particles the arrangement of the particles represented by the , or energy of phase. get more about my Cheap Essay Writing Service This was contrasted by the regions of the curve where there was a natural process , and therein case we recognized that the energy

    ReplyDelete
  4. The jackets that we sell are replicas of the coats worn by top television celebrities because it is a growing trend to copy them when it comes to fashion. These celebrities have really become the trendsetters. This leisure was hitherto in reach of only the rich and the rest could only dream about it. But now these jackets are available for all people who want to buy them because of our affordable prices. So we welcome you to come and buy celebrity jackets of excellent quality and know more about us and our products!
    Shearling Bomber Leather Jacket

    ReplyDelete
  5. I never get good at writing homework assignments, no matter how hard I tried until I found the homework help where they do any writing work to order.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Music is my life. But unfortunately my parents are against what they call my hobbies. They want to get a higher education and find a prestigious job. And yet we agreed that I would study and, in return, do what I loved. But written assignments take a lot of time and I decided to order writing works on this site https://grademiners.com/ They work quickly, the author is professionals in their field. The work is done on time. I give it the highest mark, thank you! And I will recommend it.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Super service for helping students during writing assignments. Professional performers will always come to your aid educibly login I appeal to the guys more than once and I will be in the future. Their work suits me completely. It can be seen that people who know their business are working. Recommend.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Wow! Nice article. Good Information Shared by the Author. When you Donate Zakat with us, we use it to assist with battling destitution through feasible change or give quick crisis help when emergency hits. Through your liberal Zakat or Sadaqah gift, kids will get food, medication and schooling to work toward a more joyful, more promising time to come

    ReplyDelete
  9. MrGeekDMA is #1 Digital Marketing Agency . We provides high quality of DMA Services like SEO, PPC Google Ads, FB to clients our in USA, Canada, UK & Pakistan.

    ReplyDelete
  10. If you want to add some details on your blog then you have to read blogs of different sites. It can happens with the use nordvpn software. It is because you can apply for the nordvpn 3-year plan to get this service at reasonable prie without log.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Clock In Clock Out Systems These systems help to calculate work hours, break hours and also overtime hours. Traditionally these systems were a hardware clock that employees would insert their time card into and the hardware would punch time onto it

    ReplyDelete
  12. Shafi Dropship helps you to launch your turnkey dropship store without hiring designers. shopify dropshipping stores Get your own money making dropshipping stores in USA, UK & Canada.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Wow! Nice article. Good Information Shared by the Author. When you Donate Zakat with us, we use it to assist with battling destitution through feasible change or give quick crisis help when emergency hits. Through your liberal Zakat or Sadaqah gift, kids will get food, Pay Zakat Onlinemedication and schooling to work toward a more joyful, more promising time to come.

    ReplyDelete
  14. I like this post! Our service https://expertpaperwriter.com/paperhelp-review/ make writing essays easy for you. Most of our academic writers have undergone the same process of studying at a university and realize what a nerve wrecking task it can be to complete all your essays on time; especially when writing descriptive and analytical topics which involve large amounts of research and dedication to fulfill the basic requirements expected by the instructors.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Hello friend, thank you for sharing such an interesting article, and best of luck on your next one. I'm currently a freelance writer offering the best essay writing service in a company called SmartWrite. But I also share content on different ways to make money online. Looking forward to reading more of your articles.

    ReplyDelete
  16. I'm having so much fun reading this fantastic post and I think it's great to have such a wonderful post here. You did such a great job. Are you looking for the Fast Clicking game? The pro-gamer has to perform great in spacebar games. For that, you have to practice hard on the website. Visit this profile spacebar clicker and start practicing.

    ReplyDelete
  17. We present a broader range of data services, including data lakes, machine learning, predictive analytics, analytics & data warehousing, data movement, data cleaning, and data reconciliation. aws big data solution

    ReplyDelete
  18. BEST SEO search engine optimization, is the process of achieving better search engine rankings and more traffic with the ultimate goal of generating more business.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Total SMM Panel in Pakistan, Cheapest SMM panel, Buy Social Media SMM Panel YouTube Subscribers, YouTube Watch time, Instagram followers Facebook page likes.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Total SMM Panel Buy cheap and automatic Instagram ,YouTube, TikTok & Facebook likes, followers views and subscribers from best
    SMM Panel for resellers and buyers.

    ReplyDelete

  21. Technolom is #1 SEO Services Company providing best SEO Services for Local & International Business.
    Best SEO Agency in USA, UK, Lahore, Pakistan, KSA & UAE.

    ReplyDelete