Saturday, August 20, 2011

The Density Dunk: Using Inquiry & Problem-Based Learning to Teach the Density Concept

Density is an important concept in the physical and life sciences. Density carries a significant physical meaning that relates the amount of mass an object possesses to the volume it occupies. Yet this unique property of matter is often separated from its physical meaning to instead focus on the calculation of quantities associated with density. Students do not develop a strong conceptual sense of density, despite the fact that many students can perform density calculations. Students' reasoning should not be sequestered from the calculations they perform (Reif, 1995); however, often through the use of algorithmic teaching methods, the learning that is displayed and is not a true indication of conceptual attainment learning that has taken place. Students "fake it to make it," which is to say they can perform the calculations without having any sense of what it all physically means. This later leads to learning that cannot be transferred to other contexts outside of the original learned algorithm or typical practice problems (Darling-Hammond, Low, Rossbach, & Nelson (2003).

When density is presented with only minimal attention on the concept itself, students lose sight of the physical implications of density and become imbued with a sense that density is just another equation they have to memorize and use. This is very poignantly illustrated with the use of the "density triangle" or any variation thereof (see right.) Knowledge of how to use this triangle algorithm is easily acquired by most students, but this method is a gross decontextualization from the physical meaning of density, mass or volume. Furthermore, students who use the density equation to solve problems and perform calculations, or those who use the triangle algorithm, are usually just shown to do so by their teacher through some form direct instruction. This further obfuscates the density concept and students' construct of a physical meaning for the equation. 

In an effort to implement research-based practices to elucidate important concepts, two adjustments to the teaching methodology associated with the density concept are suggested: 1) the learning should be active and cooperative (Marzano, 2004); and 2) the physical meaning of the density concept and related equation must be constructed with students before calculations can be performed.

Using an inquiry based approach to teach the relationship between mass and volume can help to develop the mathematical model for density as well as a conceptual sense of that relationship. This resulting equation, which should then have a physical meaning, can be used to solve problems and further develop students understanding of the density concept. The suggested instructional strategy that will be the focus here to achieve the desired learning of the density concept will be Problem-Based Learning (PBL) and will be used in sequence with the inquiry method. 

Ultimately, teachers want students to be able to use the density concept to do something, e.g., uniquely identify unknown substances, compare how fluids or solutions may interact when mixed, or to determine whether or not an object might float when put into water. These example tasks require more than a mere calculation to be successful. The PBL strategy and inquiry approach, when properly used in sequence, will allow students to construct a sense of density, derive the density equation, and solidify their knowledge as they stretch the density concept further by solving a novel problem: determining the density of a person--the density dunk tank experiment
Measurement is a very important skill in any science; similarly, the ability to interpret and compare data is essential to experimentation. Creating the opportunity for students to be actively involved in the development of those skills is an invaluable part of the scientific experience. The inquiry process, cooperative learning, and PBL each create the conditions that foster this type of learning. Each step in the sequence of this unit on density deals with problems and solutions to those problems. All steps are student-centered and constructivist. Cooperative learning groups will be explained and should be employed throughout the sequence. Steps are as follows for teaching the density concept:

Step 1.         Relationship Between Mass and Volume of Regularly Shaped Objects
Step 2.        Mass vs. Volume of Water
Step 3.         Water-Displacement for Measuring Volume of Irregularly Shaped Objects
Step 4.        Density Dunk

   Cooperative Learning (CL) Groups
All activities and experiments in this sequence should be done using cooperative learning groups. Student lab groups should be assigned to be heterogeneous, where each member of the group has a specified role. This facilitates their working together and prevents dominating lab partners from getting all of the value out of the activity. The class as a whole will serve as one cooperative learning group, but individual lab groups should be selected ahead of time (unless you have an established lab group protocol that you cannot give up.) More information on CL groups in the resources below. 

The detailed handout explaining how to conduct each of the steps in this learning progression of the density unit, and including the full lab for the density dunk, can be found here on the ChemEd handout page of my website.
The dunker goes under in the dunk tank as classmates are poised to determine their volume through water displacement

Containers of known volumes full of displaced water. The more variety of containers, the more unit conversions students will have to do
Students fill containers of known volumes with displaced water to determine the volume of the dunker
Danny, a dunk tank volunteer, is completely submerged to obtain his total body volume
Students collect the displaced water, using measuring cups, funnels, and containers of known volumes to determine the volume of the student in the dunk tank

  1. The Harvard Education VisibleThinking Project
  2. Arizona State University Modeling Instruction Program in Chemistry
  3. Modeling Chemistry Instruction Curriculum Framework Materials
  4. Problem-Based Learning, a Study Guide
  5. Cooperative Learning Groups
  6. If you are not yet ready to completely move away from direct instruction as part of your instructional sequence, you can consider integrating this Density PowerPoint

·   Collins, A., Brown, J. S., & Holum, A. (1991). Cognitive apprenticeship: Making thinking visible. American Educator, 15(3), 6-11, 38-46. 
·   Darling-Hammond, L., Low, B., Rossbach, B., & Nelson, J. (2003). The learning classroom. S. Burlington, VT: Mort Crim Communications, Inc. 
·   Levine, M. (2002). A mind at a time. New York: Simon & Schuster. 
·   Marzano, R. (2004). Classroom instruction that works: Research-based strategies for increasing student achievement. New Jersey: Prentice Hall. 
·   Reif, F. (1995). Understanding and teaching important scientific thought processes. Am. J. Phys. 63(1), 17-32.


  1. Thanks for your post. I believe that info on best virtual data room will be useful for you and for your students some day. It is a virtual cloud that can be used as file repository for business deals and audit.

  2. Density is an important concept in the physical and life sciences. Density carries a significant physical meaning that relates the amount of mass an object possesses to the volume it occupies. Smart custom writing phtos are great and show the essence of this phenomenon.

  3. You can figure out how to sing by showing yourself a similar way you can learn expressive dance by showing yourself, how to water-ski by showing yourself, how to tattoo by showing yourself, and mind medical procedure by educating yourself. As it were, you can't train something you know nothing about. in style jackets.

  4. However, all of these people may have their own preferences while doing their job. CRM advisers will eliminate this problem by providing the same training solutions. All your employees will follow the same guiding force and will, therefore, be true representatives of the business. Salesforce training in Chennai

  5. To create a better a campaign of your brand awareness and services the Google ads will provide a very good platform for the business owners, corporate sectors and the service providers around the world to reach their target audience through the Google AdWords channel. It is one of the main paid modules digital marketing courses. data science course syllabus

  6. All your views are important for learning the students new technology and art.I think new methods for learning process are the main part of education that should be learnt the teachers to make their teaching method useful for the students in schools and Universities. cheap dissertation writing service

  7. Truly, this article is really one of the very best in the history of articles. I am a antique ’Article’ collector and I sometimes read some new articles if I find them interesting. And I found this one pretty fascinating and it should go into my collection. Very good work!
    data science course in India

  8. I really like your post, To read you article I really fells amazing it was fun and knowledgeable also.
    Affordable PhD Thesis Help

  9. Really nice and interesting post. I was looking for this kind of information and enjoyed reading this one. Keep posting. Thanks for sharing.
    Artificial Intelligence Course

  10. I love your content and the lessons you share with your readers. Every time I read a post best forum I feel like I am able to take advantage of this post,

  11. สตีฟ บรูซ ได้รับรางวัลผู้จัดการทีมยอดเยี่ยม พรีเมียร์ลีก ประจำเดือนเมษายน ผู้จัดการทีม นิวคาสเซิล ยูไนเต็ด นำทีมของเขาเก็บไปได้ 8 แต้มจากการแข่งขันทั้ง 4 นัดโดยไม่เลยแม้แต่เกมเดียวช่วยให้ทีมของเขาการันตีการอยู่รอดบนลีกสูงสุดไปต่อได้อีกฤดูกาล เดอะ แม็กพายส์ ตามตีเสมอ...ufa

  12. Baccarat is actually money making and it's remarkable accessibility. Optimal In your case it's readily available that you will find pretty fascinating choices. And that is thought to be one thing that is really different And it's very something that is really prepared to hit with Pretty much the most wonderful, as well, is actually a really positive option. Furthermore, it's a really fascinating solution. It is a better way which can make money. Superbly prepar The number of best-earning baccarat will be the accessibility of generting the most money. Pretty much as practical is very well suited for you A substitute that could be assured. To a wide range of accessibility and performance And find out outstanding results also.บาคาร่า

  13. pgslot ซึ่งเกมคาสิโนออนไลน์เกมนี้เป็นเกมที่เรียกว่าเกม สล็อตเอ็กซ์โอ คุณรู้จักเกมส์เอ็กซ์โอหรือไม่ 90% ต้องรู้จักเกมส์เอ็กซ์โออย่างแน่นอนเพราะในตอนนี้เด็กนั้นเราทุกคนมักที่จะเอาก็ได้ขึ้นมา สล็อต เล่นเกมส์เอ็กซ์โอกับเพื่อนเพื่อนแล้วคุณรู้หรือไม่ว่าในปัจจุบันนี้เกมส์เอ็กซ์โอนั้นกลายมาเป็นเกมซะลอสออนไลน์ที่ให้บริการด้วยเว็บคาสิโนออนไลน์คุณสามารถเดิมพันเกมส์เอ็กซ์โอกับเว็บคาสิโนออนไลน์ได้โดยที่จะทำให้คุณนั้นสามารถสร้างกำไรจากการเล่นเกมส์เดิมพันออนไลน์ได้เราแนะนำเกมส์ชนิดนี้ให้คุณได้รู้จักก็เพราะว่าเชื่อว่าทุก

  14. I appreciate all the work you put into this blog post, helping out others with your fun and creative works. I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this article.
    Data Science Training in Hyderabad
    Data Science Course in Hyderabad

  15. Thanks for sharing this information.I love your articl.Thank you for sharing this with us.

  16. As a top security company, we are aware of the importance of hiring a security residential security in UKcompany with knowledge, experience, and high professional standards. UK Close Protection Services is such a company. We are among the leading celebrity and VIP protection agencies in London. No matter the kind of security service you need, we'll provide you with an extra layer of protection so you and your loved ones can have peace of mind.

  17. No matter your social stature, financial position or career, at UK Close top security companies in London
    Protection Services, it’s our duty to ensure that everyone feels safe and secure. In this blog post, we will walk you through the reasons for hiring a security company in London, who we believe would benefit, the services we provide at UK Close Protection Services, and our guarantee to you for the best security services in London.

  18. Thanks for sharing this awesome content, it would be helpful
    Guys just sharing, I’ve found this interesting! Check it out!

  19. May I simply just say what a relief to discover someone that actually knows what they are talking about online. You actually know how to bring an issue to light and make it important.

  20. Whether or not corporations will successfully bridge these two fields is but to be seen. Casinos usually accept all bets made by 우리카지노 patrons within an established limit, so that a patron can not win greater than a on line casino can afford to pay. Every game offered gives a on line casino a mathematical expectancy of winning, and it is rather uncommon for a on line casino to lose money on its video games, even for one day. Even lesser bettors are offered reduced-fare transportation, lodge rooms, free drinks and cigarettes whereas playing, and different inducements. While conventional casinos have been in existence a protracted time|for a very lengthy time}, the digital period has escalated the market leaders to a larger novelty. All that, however, has been achieved whereas maintaining the core of on line casino gaming intact.